Natives by Jason Kobl
Jason
Kobl's characters are rich and clearly defined, adding to the film tensions.
The father's misunderstanding and disapproval of his daughter's sexuality is
ironic when paired with his clearly Native American roots. The Native Americans
were a misunderstood and judged people by early settlers. This underlying
tension amplifies his judgement of his daughter and causes an increased
sympathy for the women's relationship in the viewer. The mother's unwillingness to hug her
daugher's girlfriend sets the tone for the visit, each callous word and gesture
highlighting the girlfriend's role as the victim. Not only does the woman's
parents keep the girlfriend at an arm's length, but the woman herself becomes
cool and embarrassed of their union. The viewer realizes that her discomfort
stems from the subtle yet palpable disapproval of the parents. The girlfriend
is further shown as the victim through her nervous, yet heartfelt, attempts to connect
with the parents, be it her gushing over her love for Lost or attempting to
make a religious connection at dinner over the name for god, the viewer can't
help but rally into her corner.
As the film
progresses, the viewer notices the daughter's desperate attempts to share her
wealth with her parents, and her parent's stubborn resistance of it. Maybe, her
parents hold some resentment over her abandoning the place she grew up. For
instance, at dinner, the father expresses his daughter's talents and there
usefulness in recent town struggles. He follows the compliment by passive
aggressively calling her, in essence, too good for the town, having left for
New York. This moment definitely reflects some tension surrounding her
departure from home, which maybe they assume to be tied to the revelation of
her unconventional sexuality.
In the end,
the girlfriend's idealism over coming out to her lover's parents combined with
the her lover's seemingly defeated resolution that her parents could never
understand and accept them despite their spiritual inclinations drives a wedge
through their relationship.
In regards
to creative decisions, I love the way the film starts with the girlfriend
walking in the sun sublimely eating an ice cream and ends with the two women
standing in the still evening on the train platform. It's creates a beautiful
imagistic dichotomy between the hopefulness of the main character verses her
eventual disillusionment.
The Anti-Social Network
The tone of this film begins with a purely comedic image of
the main character checking in to a social network at a funeral. The
character's obsession with Facebook is visually represented by social
networking icons and features that have become so embedded in his mind that
they've bled into his reality. The ridiculous and fantastic nature is
believable and comical at the same time. The viewer believes that although
he/she may not know anyone whose obsession has seeped into their daily consciousness,
that by no means rules out the possibility of someone existing with a
dependency as such. A powerful scene
that Shackleford uses to epitomize our culture's obsession with technology is
the main character trolling his social network on his couch, while the
arbitrary flash and buzz of the TV entertain the kittens and his smart phone
keeps him company on an adjacent couch cushion. This inability to find
contentment in one endeavor seems to be an epidemic in contemporary culture.
It's sad to watch our main character miss real human connections while his over
active news feed like consciousness scrolls from stimulus to stimulus. He
ditches his friend at the bar to chase girls, he blows off his responsibilities
at work to scroll his news feed, and climactically he nearly squanders a
possible love interest all in the name of technological impulses. I love that the love interest represents the
counterpoint to the main character's disconnection from reality. She creates
the opposing force in the plot, trying to coerce him from his dependency by
convicting him of his futile attempts at omnipresence that are only resulting
in his mental absence from the human connection and intimacy he's been seeking
via technology.
There's a clear connection between the technology-smitten
man and the free spirited girlfriend from Kobl's Natives. Both characters
become fixated on things to a fault. The Romeo of Social Media Facebook
obsession drives a wedge between him connecting on his date, while the
girlfriend's desperate need for her lover's parents approval creates distance
between them and seemingly dissolves their union.
Rob, you said: "In regards to creative decisions, I love the way the film starts with the girlfriend walking in the sun sublimely eating an ice cream and ends with the two women standing in the still evening on the train platform. It's creates a beautiful imagistic dichotomy between the hopefulness of the main character verses her eventual disillusionment."
ReplyDeleteI had not really picked up on the contrast between the beginning of the film (sunny, breezy, ebullient) and the ending.(night-time, quiet, pensive), though in both scenes I found symbolism in the way they were filmed and the characters' actions. I think the contrasts that you point out are very important to the arc of the film - good eye! In the beginning, Rachel seemed confident and excited (road trip! ice cream!) and by the end, she seemed worn down, uncertain, apologetic, and very tiny.